If you’ve been told you have a herniated disc—and that a cortisone shot is the next step—you’re not alone.
It’s one of the most common recommendations people hear after an MRI shows a disc bulge or herniation.
And in certain situations, it can be helpful.
But here’s what most people aren’t told:
Cortisone shots don’t fix the disc. They reduce inflammation.
That distinction matters more than most people realize—and it’s often the difference between temporary relief and long-term resolution.
Not All Herniated Disc Pain Is the Same
When people hear “herniated disc,” they often assume:
something is damaged → something needs to be fixed
But imaging doesn’t work that cleanly.
Many people have disc bulges or herniations and no pain at all.
So the better question isn’t:
👉 What showed up on my MRI?
It’s:
👉 What’s actually driving my symptoms?
In most cases, back pain falls into two broad categories:
- Inflammatory pain
- Mechanical pain
Both can exist with a herniated disc—but they behave very differently.
Why MRI Findings Don’t Always Equal Pain
This is one of the most important—and most misunderstood—parts of back pain.
Just because something shows up on an MRI doesn’t mean it’s the source of your symptoms.
In fact, research consistently shows that many people have disc bulges, herniations, and other “abnormal” findings… without any pain at all.
- A landmark study by Scott D. Boden found that over 50% of people without back pain had disc bulges on MRI
- Around 25–30% of asymptomatic individuals have disc herniations
- And by older age, disc bulges are present in more than 75% of people without symptoms
These findings increase with age. They’re common.
And in many cases, they’re simply part of normal aging—not a direct cause of pain. Kind of like wrinkles on the inside.
What This Means for You
This is where people get misled.
They get imaging.
They see something “wrong.”
And it’s assumed that’s the cause of their pain.
But the body doesn’t work that way.
Two people can have the exact same MRI finding:
- One has no pain
- The other is significantly limited
The difference isn’t just the structure.
It’s how the system is functioning.
This is why we don’t treat MRIs—we treat people.
Herniated Discs and Cortisone Shots: When Shots Actually Make Sense
Cortisone injections (epidural steroid injections) can be useful when pain is primarily inflammatory.
This tends to look like:
- constant pain
- minimal change with movement or position
- a deep, irritated or “inflamed” sensation
In these cases, calming the inflammatory response can create a window where movement becomes possible again.
But this is not the most common presentation.
Most Herniated Disc Pain Is Mechanical
Most back pain—even when a disc is involved—is mechanical.
That means it’s driven by:
- how your spine moves
- how load is distributed
- how well your muscles support the system
Mechanical pain often looks like:
- worse with prolonged sitting
- better with walking or changing positions
- responsive to movement, stretching, or exercise
These patterns are important.
Because when symptoms improve with movement, the solution is rarely to suppress the system.
It’s to restore how the system functions.
The Real Problem Most People Miss
A disc doesn’t function in isolation.
It’s part of a system.
When that system is:
- stiff in certain areas
- overworking in others
- lacking support where it needs it
…the disc ends up taking more stress than it should.
That’s when irritation happens.
Not necessarily because something “tore.”
But because the system wasn’t distributing load well in the first place.
Why Treating Inflammation Alone Falls Short
Cortisone injections address inflammation.
They do not address:
- movement dysfunction
- strength deficits
- coordination issues
- load tolerance
So while symptoms may temporarily improve, the underlying issue often remains.
And this is why pain frequently returns.
What Actually Changes the Outcome
If the issue is mechanical, long-term improvement comes from addressing:
- how your body moves
- how your spine is supported
- how load is managed over time
This typically includes:
- restoring mobility where it’s limited
- improving movement patterns
- building strength in the muscles that support the spine
When these pieces are in place, the disc becomes far less reactive.
Not because it disappeared.
But because the system around it improved.
How to Tell What Type of Pain You Have
You don’t need an advanced test to start getting clarity.
Pay attention to how your symptoms behave:
If your pain:
- improves with movement
- changes with position
- responds to activity
👉 it’s likely mechanical
If your pain:
- feels constant and has little variability at all
- doesn’t change with movement
- feels inflamed or irritated
👉 inflammation may be a larger factor
What We See at Alpine Fit in Boulder
This is one of the most common scenarios we see.
People come in with:
- an MRI showing a disc issue
- a recommendation for injections or surgery
- ongoing pain that hasn’t fully resolved
But once we assess how they actually move, a different picture often emerges.
We identify:
- where the system is overloaded
- where support is lacking
- where movement is inefficient
And when those things change, symptoms often improve.
Not because the MRI changed.
But because the system did.
When to Consider a Cortisone Shot
Cortisone injections can still be appropriate in certain situations.
They may help when:
- inflammation is clearly the dominant driver
- pain is severe and limiting all movement
- you need short-term relief to begin rehab
But they should be used strategically, not as a default.
The Bottom Line
A herniated disc on an MRI does not automatically require an injection.
And a cortisone shot does not fix the underlying issue.
It can reduce inflammation.
But long-term improvement almost always comes from addressing how your body moves and functions.
Need Help Figuring It Out?
If you’re dealing with back pain or trying to decide whether an injection makes sense, the most important step is understanding what’s actually driving your symptoms.
At Alpine Fit, we take a deeper look at:
- how your body moves
- how your spine is supported
- and what your system needs to improve
👉 Request a Discovery Visit
We’ll help you determine whether your pain is mechanical, inflammatory, or both—and give you a clear path forward.





